Understanding Project Management, Quantity Surveying, Building Surveying and Contract Administration
Construction projects can involve a surprisingly long list of professional roles. Project Managers, Quantity Surveyors, Building Surveyors, Employer’s Agents, Contract Administrators, architects and engineers may all be involved at different stages.
For clients who do not work in construction every day, it is not always obvious where one role ends and another begins. Part of the reason is that the roles do not always sit neatly with separate people. A Quantity Surveyor might also act as Employer’s Agent. A Building Surveyor might administer the building contract. On another project, a dedicated Project Manager may coordinate the wider consultant team.
The right arrangement depends on the project, how it is procured and the level of support the client needs. Rather than focusing too heavily on job titles, it is often more useful to understand the main responsibilities and how they fit together.
Project Manager
A Project Manager is generally concerned with the overall organisation and coordination of the project. This can include establishing the programme, coordinating the consultant team, monitoring progress, managing actions and risks, and helping decisions to be made at the right time.
The Project Manager will not necessarily carry out all of the specialist work. The Quantity Surveyor may provide the cost advice, the Building Surveyor may deal with technical matters and the architect may lead on design. The Project Manager helps bring those different workstreams together and keeps the overall position visible to the client.
Employer’s Agent
Employer’s Agent is a role associated particularly with Design and Build procurement. The Employer’s Agent acts for the client in administering the building contract. The role can include managing communications with the contractor, issuing instructions and notices where required, monitoring progress and dealing with contractual matters during construction.
An Employer’s Agent does not have to be someone whose sole profession is ‘Employer’s Agent’. A Quantity Surveyor, Building Surveyor or Project Manager with the appropriate experience can take on the role. Combining roles can often be practical because the person administering the contract may already have a detailed understanding of the project’s cost, technical or management position.
This is an arrangement we regularly see at Cyril Orchard Group. On a number of our commercial and education projects, our appointment has combined Quantity Surveying with the Employer’s Agent role, giving the client a consistent point of contact across cost and contract matters.
Contract Administrator
Depending on the contract, this may involve issuing instructions, dealing with applications for payment, monitoring progress, assessing extensions of time and managing the procedures leading to practical completion.
Again, Contract Administrator describes the role being carried out rather than necessarily the person’s underlying profession. A Building Surveyor will often act as Contract Administrator on refurbishment, repair and maintenance projects because they may already have surveyed the building, prepared the specification and developed the works. A Quantity Surveyor or another suitably experienced consultant may also undertake the role, depending on the project and appointment.
Quantity Surveyor
The Quantity Surveyor’s primary focus is cost and commercial management. The role can start well before construction, with order of cost estimates and cost planning, before moving into procurement, tender analysis, valuations, financial reporting, change control and final account work.
At Cyril Orchard Group, our Quantity Surveying services also include Bills of Quantities, value engineering, procurement support and Insurance Reinstatement Cost Assessments.
In practice, a Quantity Surveyor’s involvement is rarely confined to the figures. Cost decisions are closely connected to procurement, programme, design and risk. That wider understanding can also make a Quantity Surveyor well placed to undertake an Employer’s Agent or Project Management role where appropriate.
Building Surveyor
Building Surveying covers a broad range of technical property and construction matters. Our work includes condition surveys, defect diagnosis, planned maintenance, dilapidations and Schedules of Condition, Party Wall matters, measured surveys, architectural design and planning support.
Building Surveyors can also become closely involved in delivering the works they have helped to define. A Building Surveyor may inspect a property, identify necessary repairs, prepare the specification or design and then act as Contract Administrator while the work is carried out.
This is why the boundary between surveying, contract administration and project management can sometimes appear blurred. It is not necessarily duplication. Often, it reflects one professional taking responsibility for several connected aspects of the project.
So, who is managing the project?
Potentially more than one person, with each taking responsibility for a different part of the project.
On one scheme, a Project Manager may coordinate the overall programme, a Quantity Surveyor may control cost and a separate Contract Administrator may administer the building contract. On another, the client’s Quantity Surveyor may also act as Employer’s Agent and become the main point of contact throughout construction. On a refurbishment project, a Building Surveyor may lead the technical work and administer the contract, supported by a Quantity Surveyor on cost.
There is no single structure that is right for every project. What matters is that responsibilities are agreed at the outset, there are no gaps or unnecessary overlaps, and the client knows who is responsible when advice or a decision is needed.
A joined-up approach
This overlap between disciplines is something we see regularly at Cyril Orchard Group. Our Quantity Surveyors and Building Surveyors work across different stages of projects, supported by Project Management, Contract Administration and Employer’s Agent appointments where required.
The team needed for a small refurbishment can look very different from the team needed for a new commercial building or a major maintenance programme. The aim is not to appoint a separate consultant for every possible title. It is to put together a proportionate team with the right experience and clearly understood responsibilities.
Ultimately, a well-managed project depends less on job titles and more on clear responsibility, good information and the right advice at the right time.
If you would like to discuss any of these roles in more detail, or find out how Cyril Orchard Group could assist with your project, please contact our team.
Contact Cyril Orchard Group
We are Chartered Quantity and Building Surveyors working across the UK, with offices in Telford, Shropshire and Folkestone, Kent.
Address: West Six, Hortonwood West, Telford, TF1 6AH or Unit 3, 1st Floor, The Workshop, 32–40 Tontine Street, Folkestone, CT20 1JU
Email: telford@cyrilorchard.co.uk or folkestone@cyrilorchard.co.uk
Phone: 01952 608445 or 01303 851000
Opening hours: Monday to Friday, 8:30am–5:00pm
Website: www.cyrilorchard.co.uk